The interplay between traditional dispute resolution institutions and the formal justice system in Ethiopia: The case of the Jaarsa Biyyaa
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/ajcr.v24i1.18114Abstract
Ethiopia has extensive experience with traditional dispute resolution practices that function parallel to the formal courts in various parts of the country. In pluralistic justice systems where state and non-state justice systems operate, how the state responds to the situation is significant. Through a study of cases prosecuted by the Jaarsa Biyyaa institution of the Arsi Oromo people, this article explores whether and how traditional dispute resolution institutions (TDRIs) interact with the formal courts and the impact of this interaction, if any, on the culture of the Arsi Oromo people. The findings show a shared interest in jurisdiction (predominantly over criminal matters) and competition between the Jaarsa Biyyaa and the formal courts. Moreover, there is also a practice of cooperation and complementarity between the Jaarsa Biyyaa and the formal justice system (FJS) where each recognises the other in practice. For the Arsi Oromo people, such mutual recognition is an opportunity to maintain the clanship organisation. More importantly, mutual recognition promotes conflict management in the community, which serves as a valuable lesson for the country. Other than the opportunities that arise, there are constraints such as the interruption of Jaarsummaa (elders reconciliation), broken social bonds and enmity.
References
Abdella, A. and Amenew, B. (2008) customary dispute resolution institutions in Oromia Region: The Case of Jaarsa Biyyaa. In: Pankhurst, A. and Assefa, G. eds. Grass-roots Justice in Ethiopia: The Contribution of Customary Dispute Resolution. Addis-Abeba, Cenre francias des études éthiopiennes. pp. 169‒184.
Abera, M. (2020) The interplay of customary and formal legal systems among the Tulama Oromo. In: Epple, A., and Assef, G. eds. Legal Pluralism in Ethiopia: Actors, challenges, and solutions. Transcript Verlag, pp. 115‒138.
Abba Gadaa. (2022) Interview with the author on 7 July. Negele Arsi. [Cassette recording in possession of author].
Abba Murtii. (2022) Interview with the author on 8 July. Negele Arsi. [Cassette recording in possession of author].
Assefa, G. (2020) Towards widening the constitutional space for customary justice systems in Ethiopia. In: Epple, A. and Assef, G. eds. Legal Pluralism in Ethiopia: Actors, challenges, and solutions. Addis-Abeba, Cenre francias des études éthiopiennes. pp. 43‒61.
Connolly, B. (2005) Non-state justice systems and the state: proposals for recognition typology. Connecticut Law Review, 38 (2), pp. 239‒294.
Degefa, A. (2013) Legal Pluralism in Multicultural Setting. Law and Development, and Legal Pluralism in Ethiopia. The Danish Institute for Human Rights, Copenhagen.
Disputant. (2022) Interview with the author on 25 July. Negele Arsi. [Cassette recording in possession of author].
Disputant. (2022) Interview with the author on 25 July. Negele Arsi. [Cassette recording in possession of author].
Disputant. (2022) Interview with the author on 27 July. Negele Arsi. [Cassette recording in possession of author].
Elder. (2022) Interview with the author on 14 July. Negele Arsi. [Cassette recording in possession of author].
Elder. (2022) Interview with the author on 21 July. Negele Arsi. [Cassette recording in possession of author].
Elder. (2022) Interview with the author on 23 July. Negele Arsi. [Cassette recording in possession of author].
Enyew, E. (2013) A move towards restorative justice in Ethiopia: accommodating customary dispute resolution mechanisms with the criminal justice system. Master’s thesis, University of Tromsø.
Enyew, E. (2014) Ethiopian customary dispute resolution mechanisms: Forms of restorative justice? African Journal on Conflict Resolution, 14 (1), pp. 125‒154.
Epple, S. and Assefa, G. (2020) Legal pluralism in Ethiopia: Actors, challenges, and solutions. Transcript Verlag.
Fita, K. (2021) A Quest for a Wider Mandates to Customary Justice Institutions in Ethiopia: A Particular Emphasis on ‘Yaa’aa Yaaboo’ (a Qaallu Court). Journal of Legal Subjects (JLS) ISSN 2815-097X, 1 (01), 8‒17.
Forsyth, M. (2007) A typology of relationships between state and non-state justice systems. The Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law, 39 (56), pp. 67‒112.
Ghebretekle, T. and Rammala, M. (2018) Traditional African conflict resolution: the case of South Africa and Ethiopia. Mizan Law Review, 12 (2), pp. 325‒347.
Griffiths, J. (1986) What is legal pluralism? The journal legal pluralism and unofficial laws, 18 (24), pp. 1‒55.
Hassen, M. (1994) Some aspects of Oromo history that have been misunderstood. Journal of Oromo Studies, 1 (2), pp. 77‒90.
Hayyuu. (2022) Interview with the author on 10 July. Negele Arsi. [Cassette recording in possession of author].
Judge. (2022) Interview with the author on 8 August. Negele Arsi. [Cassette recording in possession of author].
Legal practitioner. (2022) Interview with the author on 25 July. Negele Arsi. [Cassette recording in possession of author].
Melton, A. (1995) Indigenous justice systems and tribal society. Judicature, 79 (3), pp. 126‒133.
Merry S.E. (1988) Legal Pluralism. Law and Society Rev, 22 (5), pp. 869‒896.
Moore S.F. (1986) Social facts and Fabrications: Customary law on Kilimanjaro, 1880-1980. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Negele town Culture and Tourism Bureau official (2022) Interview with the author on 5 August. Negele Arsi. [Cassette recording in possession of author].
Negele town Culture and Tourism Bureau official. (2022) Interview with the author on 11 August. Negele Arsi. [Cassette recording in possession of author].
Pankhurst, A. and Assefa, G. eds. (2008) Grassroots Justice in Ethiopia: The Contribution of Customary Dispute Resolution. Addis Ababa, Centre francais d’études ethiopiennes. pp. 1‒76.
Perrin J. (2017) Legal pluralism as a method of interpretation: A methodological approach to decolonizing indigenous peoples’ land rights under international law. Universitas, XV (26), pp. 23‒60.
Pospisil L. (1981) Modern and Traditional Administrative Justice in New Guinea. Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law, 13 (19), pp. 93‒116.
Qora mataa. (2022) Interview with the author on 8 July. Negele Arsi. [Cassette recording in possession of author].
Qora Milaa. (2022) Interview with the author on 13 July. Negele Arsi. [Cassette recording in possession of author].
Sirna, Z. (2012) Ethiopia: when the Gadaa democracy rules in a federal state. Bridging indigenous institutions of governance to modern democracy. Master's thesis, Universitetet i Tromsø.
Sirna, Z. and Temesgen, Y. (2020) Blood feud in North Shäwa: Exploring the contradiction between the customary and State Criminal Justice System. Haramaya Law Review, 9 (1), 39–53.
Swenson, G. (2018) Legal pluralism in theory and practice. International Studies Review, 20 (3), pp. 438‒462.
Tamanaha, B.Z. (2008) Understanding legal pluralism: past to present, local to global. Sydney law review, 30 (3), pp. 375‒411.
Terfa, M. (2018) Exploring the current practices of Jaarsumma as indigenous conflict resolution mechanisms: The case of Dambi Dollo Town. International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications, 8 (3), pp. 15‒19.
The Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia. (1995) The Constitution of the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia. Addis Ababa, Mega Printing Enterprise.
Worku, S. (2020) Examining potentials of indigenous conflict resolution institutions in creating cohesive community beyond resolving conflicts: The case of Arsi Oromo, Ethiopia. Journal of Politics & Governance, 8 (11–12), pp. 9‒25.
Wourji, T. (2012) Coexistence between the Formal and Informal Justice Systems in Ethiopia: Challenges and Prospects. African Journal of Legal Studies, 5 (3), 269‒293.
Yntiso, G. (2014) Systematizing knowledge about customary laws in Ethiopia. Journal of Ethiopian Law, 26 (2), pp. 28‒54.
Yntiso, G. (2020) Understanding customary laws in the context of legal pluralism. In: Epple, A., and Assef, G. eds. Legal Pluralism in Ethiopia: Actors, challenges, and solutions. pp. 71‒93.
Zeleke, M. (2010) Ye Shakoch Chilot (the court of sheiks): a traditional institution of conflict resolution in Oromiya Zone of Amhara Regional State, Ethiopia. African Journal on Conflict Resolution, 10 (1), pp. 63‒84.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 African Journal on Conflict Resolution
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}